Inclusion: The Stereotypes Pre-service Teachers Associate with Pupils with Special Educational Needs

"Autistic pupils are perceived as particularly competent and less warm, pupils with Down syndrome as particularly warm and less competent, and pupils with dyslexia as less competent and also relatively less warm," says Charlotte Schell, summarizing the core findings of the investigation conducted in Germany. DIPF researcher Schell is the lead author of an article in the journal "Teaching and Teacher Education", in which the results have now been published. In comparison, autistic pupils were perceived as the most competent and least warm, while children with Down syndrome were perceived as the most warm and least competent. Children and adolescents with dyslexia were in the middle of the comparison in each case.

Numerous individual stereotypes mentioned by pre-service teachers were systematically incorporated into the overarching categories of "competent" and "warm ". Some of these diverse attributions were particularly widespread. "For example, there was a strong tendency among pre-service teachers to see autistic pupils as highly gifted and introverted, pupils with Down syndrome as good-natured and awkward and pupils with dyslexia as lazy and low achieving," explains Schell.

Even if such stereotypes may apply to individuals, they are too generalized and ignore individual differences between pupils, as the researcher points out: "It falls short to put all pupils in the same box. They have specific behaviors and abilities that differ greatly from one another. They therefore need individual support." For example, if teachers consider a child to be very intelligent or even highly gifted based on an autism diagnosis, they may overlook their needs and not provide them with enough support. After all, many autistic pupils are not gifted. In turn, if a child with dyslexia is seen as lazy based on stereotypes, teachers may ask them to work harder instead of providing targeted support according to their needs.

The scientific investigation

For their investigation, the DIPF team worked with pre-service teachers who were at different stages of their studies, had taken different subjects and were studying for different school types. In a preliminary study, the researchers first conducted interviews with 13 of these students in which they were asked to name stereotypes that they associate with the groups mentioned. This revealed a broad spectrum of attributions - such as impulsive, unintelligent, but also open or savant.

The researchers incorporated the results of the first study into a standardized questionnaire in order to record the empirical characteristics of the stereotypes in connection with the three groups of pupils. A total of 213 pre-service teachers completed this questionnaire in a larger second study. The strength of the individual attributions was then statistically processed and assigned to overarching categories using factor analysis.

Implications and further research

The studies were carried out as part of the research project "Stereo-Disk - Stereotypes as obstacles for professional diagnostics in an inclusive school context" funded by the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research. As part of the project, the DIPF is developing educational programs for teachers to reduce the impact of stereotypes on their assessments of children with special educational needs - for example, seminars that deepen knowledge about the educational needs of individual groups and diagnostic skills. The current studies highlight the need for such programs.

For future studies, the researchers have developed a model on how individual stereotypical attributions can be structured even better. Based on their investigations, they recommend classifying them into the categories "academic competence", "warmth", "social skills" and "behavioural problems". Charlotte Schell emphasizes that further research on the topic would be useful: "We looked at the stereotypes only in pre-service teachers and only for three of the pupil groups in particular need of support," says the DIPF researcher. The project team is also currently investigating the effects of stereotypes on behavior in more detail.

The article on the two studies is freely available:

Schell, C., Dignath, C., Kleen, H., John, N. & Kunter, M. (2024). Judging a book by its cover? Investigating pre-service teachers' stereotypes towards pupils with special educational needs. Teaching and Teacher Education, 142, 104526, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2024.104526

Contact

Study: Charlotte Schell, DIPF, +49 (0)69 24708-483, Yy5zY2hlbGxAZGlwZi5kZQ==
Press: Philip Stirm, DIPF, +49 (0)69 24708-123, cC5zdGlybUBkaXBmLmRl, cHJAZGlwZi5kZQ==